I've been googling this off and on for days but haven't seen anyone else with the exact same issue, nor do I know what to call this problem.
I've tried with hardware accelerated decoding off and on without any changes. It looks like it's holding just the bottom part of the previous frame into the next one.
I've also confirmed there is nothing wrong with the file itself. I currently have the video on an external drive, I moved it over to a 2nd PC with VLC media player and it ran the same sections without any problems. The issue is easy to replicate as it will always occur at the same timestamps. In addition to this, I've also been able to get this problem to occur in MPC-BE at the exact same timestamp and only on the current computer that I'm on. The problem doesn't occur in MPV. I'm just very stumped here.