VLC 3.3.0 beta 7 have some bug in Android 10 on select subtitles and group videos

[jamesmccoy0405]

VLC version: 3.3.0 beta 7 (download from google play)
Android version: 10
Phone infermation: Essential PH-1 (QQ1A.200105.032)
Bug information:
1. The video has 26 subtitles, only the first 6 subtitles can be selected in landscape mode, only the first 11 subtitles can be selected in portrait mode, and the subsequent subtitles cannot be selected afterwards
2. The 16 videos are grouped and sorted by name. The videos arranged behind the group cannot be played normally. such as: The 16 video grouping states are: Group A: 1 video, Group B: 1 video, Group C: 1 video, Group D: 10 videos, Group E: 2 videos, Group F: 1 video, playback Group F video will play the sixth video, which is the third video of group D.

[Jean-Baptiste Kempf]

1. was reported already, yes.

2. I don't understand

[jamesmccoy0405]

1. was reported already, yes.

2. I don't understand

1.Thx

2.16 vedio group by name in 6 folder.
the number of video in each folder is : 1,1,1,10,2,1.
When I open the video in the last folder, but VLC opens the sixth video in all the lists, that is, the third video in the fourth folder.

for example the video list:
1. [AJZero&Mabors Sub&MGRT]Kokoro ga sakebitagatterunda[GB&BIG5](BDrip_1080_HEVC_yuv420p10_FLAC).mkv
2. [KTXP][Sora_no_Aosa_wo_Shiru_Hito_yo][MOVIE][BIG5][1080p][BDrip].mp4
3. [Nekomoe kissaten&LoliHouse] Nakitai Watashi wa Neko o Kaburu [WebRip 1080p HEVC-10bit AAC ASSx2].mkv
4. The.Expanse.S04E01.New.Terra.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv
5. The.Expanse.S04E02.Jetsam.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv
6. The.Expanse.S04E03.Subduction.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv
7. The.Expanse.S04E04.Retrograde.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv
8. The.Expanse.S04E05.Oppressor.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv
9. The.Expanse.S04E06.Displacement.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv
10. The.Expanse.S04E07.A.Shot.In.The.Dark.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv
11. The.Expanse.S04E08.The.One-Eyed.Man.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv
12. The.Expanse.S04E09.Saeculum.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv
13. The.Expanse.S04E10.Cibola.Burn.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv
14. [Lilith-Raws] Fruits Basket S02 (2019) - 13 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv
15. [Lilith-Raws] Fruits Basket S02 (2019) - 14 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv
16. Knives.Out.利刃出鞘.2019.中英字幕.WEBrip.1080p-CS.mp4

Group by name result:
1. [AJZero&Mabors Sub&MGRT]Kokoro ga sakebitagatterunda[GB&BIG5](BDrip_1080_HEVC_yuv420p10_FLAC)
2. [KTXP][Sora_no_Aosa_wo_Shiru_Hito_yo][MOVIE][BIG5][1080p][BDrip]
3. [Nekomoe kissaten&LoliHouse] Nakitai Watashi wa Neko o Kaburu [WebRip 1080p HEVC-10bit AAC ASSx2]
4. Expanse S04E --10 videos
5. Fruits Basket S02 (2019) - 1 --2 videos
6. Knives.Out.利刃出鞘.2019.中英字幕.WEBrip.1080p-CS

When I open the Knives.Out.利刃出鞘.2019.中英字幕.WEBrip.1080p-CS.mp4
but VLC open The.Expanse.S04E03.Subduction.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv

I found this bug in too many versions, and the videos from No. 1 to No. 15 played normally.
If there is an ungrouped video after a group, the error will appear, similar to the 16th video.

Sorry, my description is not very good, but I have tried my best. Thx

[Jean-Baptiste Kempf]

This is very weird.

If you ungroup in the menu, can you play that file correctly?

[chouquette]

Hi,

Just to confirm, you're grouping by name and not by folders right?
Ideally, could you dump your database and send it to us? Go to settings -> advanced -> Dump media database, you'll find a vlc_media.db file at the root of your main storage. If you can send send it to xxx@videolan.org that would be a great help

Thanks!

[jamesmccoy0405]

This is very weird.

If you ungroup in the menu, can you play that file correctly?

Yes, if I ungroup video, all is ok.

[jamesmccoy0405]

Hi,

Just to confirm, you're grouping by name and not by folders right?
Ideally, could you dump your database and send it to us? Go to settings -> advanced -> Dump media database, you'll find a vlc_media.db file at the root of your main storage. If you can send send it to hugo@videolan.org that would be a great help

Thanks!

HI,
Yes, I just group by name.
I updated my video list today, and the updated video list and playback results will be written in the reply later.
vlc_media.db has sent an email to your mailbox via xxxx.
Thanks for your help.

[jamesmccoy0405]

The new video list, group result and playback results:
ⅰ 1. [AJZero&Mabors Sub&MGRT]Kokoro ga sakebitagatterunda[GB&BIG5](BDrip_1080_HEVC_yuv420p10_FLAC).mkv is ok
ⅱ 2. [KTXP][Sora_no_Aosa_wo_Shiru_Hito_yo][MOVIE][BIG5][1080p][BDrip].mp4 is ok
ⅲ 3. [Nekomoe kissaten&LoliHouse] Nakitai Watashi wa Neko o Kaburu [WebRip 1080p HEVC-10bit AAC ASSx2].mkv is ok
ⅳ [SBSUB][CONAN][DR143
├ 4. [SBSUB][CONAN][DR143][1080P][AVC_AAC][CHS_JP](097617DB).mp4 is ok
└ 5. [SBSUB][CONAN][DR143][1080P][HEVC_AAC][CHS_CHT_JP](B8CFF0C4).mkv is ok
ⅴ 6. [梦蓝字幕组]NewDoraemon 哆啦A梦新番[611][2020.07.11][生物折纸&冒险降落伞][AVC][720P][GB_JP][MP4].mp4 is error, and play the [SBSUB][CONAN][DR143][1080P][HEVC_AAC][CHS_CHT_JP](B8CFF0C4).mkv
ⅵ 7. [Lilith-Raws] Bessatsu Olympia Kyklos - 08 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv is error, and play the [梦蓝字幕组]NewDoraemon 哆啦A梦新番[611][2020.07.11][生物折纸&冒险降落伞][AVC][720P][GB_JP][MP4].mp4
ⅶ Expanse S04E10 Cibola Burn NTG
├ 8. The.Expanse.S04E10.Cibola.Burn.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv is ok
└ 9. The.Expanse.S04E10.Cibola.Burn.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.eng&chi.mkv is ok
ⅷ Fruits Basket S02 (2019) 1
├ 10. [Lilith-Raws] Fruits Basket S02 (2019) - 13 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv is ok
├ 11. [Lilith-Raws] Fruits Basket S02 (2019) - 14 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv is ok
└ 12. [Lilith-Raws] Fruits Basket S02 (2019) - 15 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv is ok
ⅸ 13. Knives.Out.利刃出鞘.2019.中英字幕.WEBrip.1080p-CS.mp4 is error, and play the The.Expanse.S04E10.Cibola.Burn.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.eng&chi.mkv
ⅹ 14. 世界奇妙物语20夏季特别篇.Yonimo.Kimyouna.Monogatari.20.Natsu.no.SP.Chi_Jap.HDTVrip.1280X720.mp4 is error, and play the [Lilith-Raws] Fruits Basket S02 (2019) - 13 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv
ⅺ 雪国列车.Snowpiercer.S01E
├ 15. 雪国列车.Snowpiercer.S01E09.中英字幕.WEBrip.720P-人人影视.mp4 is ok
└ 16. 雪国列车.Snowpiercer.S01E10.End.中英字幕.WEBrip.720P-人人影视.mp4 is ok

ⅰ ⅱ ⅲ ⅳ ⅴ…just for group number
1 2 3 4 5…just for video number

I had do something:
1. Clean VLC app's storage, the error is also here
2. ungroup ⅶ Expanse S04E10 Cibola Burn NTG, but the two video are behind the Knives.Out.利刃出鞘.2019.中英字幕.WEBrip.1080p-CS.mp4, and the playback results is error
├ The.Expanse.S04E10.Cibola.Burn.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv is error. and play the [Lilith-Raws] Fruits Basket S02 (2019) - 14 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv
└ The.Expanse.S04E10.Cibola.Burn.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.eng&chi.mkv is error, and play the [Lilith-Raws] Fruits Basket S02 (2019) - 15 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv
3. regroup the The.Expanse.S04E10.Cibola.Burn.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv and The.Expanse.S04E10.Cibola.Burn.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.eng&chi.mkv, the two video is ok.

My thoughts on the cause of this bug:
After group video by name
a) Video with the same name in the group, search the sequential position of the video in the group during playback.
b) Videos that do not belong to the same name group, that is, there is only one video in a group, during playback, according to the grouping position, search for the sequential position of the video in all videos, for example, if the video is in the sixth group, then search for the sixth in all videos Videos, this is wrong.

My thoughts on solving the bug:
After group video by name, the Video with the same name in the group are behind Videos that are not group as the same name group (one video in one group).
Just like in Windows and Linux systems, the folders are in front of the files, and then sorted by name.
the result as:
ⅰ 1. [AJZero&Mabors Sub&MGRT]Kokoro ga sakebitagatterunda[GB&BIG5](BDrip_1080_HEVC_yuv420p10_FLAC).mkv
ⅱ 2. [KTXP][Sora_no_Aosa_wo_Shiru_Hito_yo][MOVIE][BIG5][1080p][BDrip].mp4
ⅲ 3. [Nekomoe kissaten&LoliHouse] Nakitai Watashi wa Neko o Kaburu [WebRip 1080p HEVC-10bit AAC ASSx2].mkv
ⅳ 6. [梦蓝字幕组]NewDoraemon 哆啦A梦新番[611][2020.07.11][生物折纸&冒险降落伞][AVC][720P][GB_JP][MP4].mp4
ⅴ 7. [Lilith-Raws] Bessatsu Olympia Kyklos - 08 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv
ⅵ 13. Knives.Out.利刃出鞘.2019.中英字幕.WEBrip.1080p-CS.mp4
ⅶ 14. 世界奇妙物语20夏季特别篇.Yonimo.Kimyouna.Monogatari.20.Natsu.no.SP.Chi_Jap.HDTVrip.1280X720.mp4
ⅷ [SBSUB][CONAN][DR143
├ 4. [SBSUB][CONAN][DR143][1080P][AVC_AAC][CHS_JP](097617DB).mp4
└ 5. [SBSUB][CONAN][DR143][1080P][HEVC_AAC][CHS_CHT_JP](B8CFF0C4).mkv
ⅸ Expanse S04E10 Cibola Burn NTG
├ 8. The.Expanse.S04E10.Cibola.Burn.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.mkv
└ 9. The.Expanse.S04E10.Cibola.Burn.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.H.264-NTG.eng&chi.mkv
ⅹ Fruits Basket S02 (2019) 1
├ 10. [Lilith-Raws] Fruits Basket S02 (2019) - 13 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv
├ 11. [Lilith-Raws] Fruits Basket S02 (2019) - 14 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv
└ 12. [Lilith-Raws] Fruits Basket S02 (2019) - 15 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MKV].mkv
ⅺ 雪国列车.Snowpiercer.S01E
├ 15. 雪国列车.Snowpiercer.S01E09.中英字幕.WEBrip.720P-人人影视.mp4
└ 16. 雪国列车.Snowpiercer.S01E10.End.中英字幕.WEBrip.720P-人人影视.mp4

Thanks.

[jamesmccoy0405]

Another thoughts on solving the bug:
Make one video in one group as similar as more same name videos in one group, then sort group by name. User should choose the group before choose video.
make it like group a, group b, group c, group d, group e
not group a, video A, group b, video B, video C.

[chouquette]

I can't reproduce with the same file names on my phone, I reached out privately with the OP to gather more info/logs

[Lotesdelere]

Maybe it has something to do with the brackets in filenames ?

https://forum.videolan.org/viewtopic.php?f=35&t=153592
https://forum.videolan.org/viewtopic.php?f=35&t=152080

[jamesmccoy0405]

I can't reproduce with the same file names on my phone, I reached out privately with the OP to gather more info/logs

Thank for your help, the logcat files has been sent for you by email.

[jamesmccoy0405]

Maybe it has something to do with the brackets in filenames ?

https://forum.videolan.org/viewtopic.php?f=35&t=153592
https://forum.videolan.org/viewtopic.php?f=35&t=152080

It didn't work, I deleted all the brackets and there was still a issues.

[Aza]

I just tried reproducing it without any luck.
Could you please provide a screencast video of the issue?

[jamesmccoy0405]

I just tried reproducing it without any luck.
Could you please provide a screencast video of the issue?

Thank you for your attempt, but I found that The VideoLAN Forums could not send the video, I will try to put the video on youtube, please wait, thank you.

[jamesmccoy0405]

I just tried reproducing it without any luck.
Could you please provide a screencast video of the issue?

Thanks to Hugo Beauzée-Luyssen aka. chouquette for posting this issue on the vlc code (https://code.videolan.org/videolan/vlc- ... ssues/1421), which contains the log file I had provided, please also you help check it. The video may need to wait a bit. Thank you.

[jamesmccoy0405]

I just tried reproducing it without any luck.
Could you please provide a screencast video of the issue?

The screencast video had post in youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3yagV8LxJWc&t=17s

[Aza]

Thanks you. I will take a look.

[Jean-Baptiste Kempf]

https://code.videolan.org/videolan/vlc- ... ssues/1421

[jamesmccoy0405]

The group video bug is also in version 3.3.0 RC1.

[jamesmccoy0405]

The bug of select subtitles is also in version 3.3.0 RC1.

[Aza]

The bug of select subtitles is also in version 3.3.0 RC1.

It was indeed only fixed in portrait mode. Should be fixed in landscape in RC 2

The group video bug is also in version 3.3.0 RC1.

We were not able to reproduce it and nobody reported something similar. I tried to understand what could happen and failed.

[jamesmccoy0405]

The bug of select subtitles is also in version 3.3.0 RC1.

It was indeed only fixed in portrait mode. Should be fixed in landscape in RC 2

The group video bug is also in version 3.3.0 RC1.

We were not able to reproduce it and nobody reported something similar. I tried to understand what could happen and failed.

Thank you very much, I just want to report on the bug fixes in the current version.
I very much hope that the second problem will only appear on my device, and that is not a big problem, thank you.

[jamesmccoy0405]

The bug of select subtitles is also in version 3.3.0 RC1.

It was indeed only fixed in portrait mode. Should be fixed in landscape in RC 2

The group video bug is also in version 3.3.0 RC1.

We were not able to reproduce it and nobody reported something similar. I tried to understand what could happen and failed.

The bug of select subtitles is fixed in version 3.3.0 RC2, thanks.

[jamesmccoy0405]

The bug of select subtitles is also in version 3.3.0 RC1.

It was indeed only fixed in portrait mode. Should be fixed in landscape in RC 2

The group video bug is also in version 3.3.0 RC1.

We were not able to reproduce it and nobody reported something similar. I tried to understand what could happen and failed.

The bug of select subtitles is fixed in version 3.3.0 RC2, thanks.

If the bug of the grouped video cannot be reproduced, just forget it