Page 1 of 1

AAC+ encoding through 3GPP spec. sources

Posted: 22 Mar 2006 00:50
by sean_malice
AAC+ sources are available as part of the 3GPP specifications.
http://www.3gpp.org/ftp/Specs/

So why can't AAC+ encoding be added to VLC ?

This guy already made a CLI encoder out of it, and i don't see anyone suing him for it.
http://forum.dbpoweramp.com/showthread.php?t=7107

Re: AAC+ encoding through 3GPP spec. sources

Posted: 24 Apr 2006 16:53
by tipok
It will be good to do this.
But at first FFMPEG have to encode to this format (because AAC+ not GNU/GPL licensed)

Posted: 26 Apr 2006 11:45
by The DJ
These specs are usually not GPL compatible indeed. So new encoders need to be developed.

Posted: 26 Apr 2006 20:16
by tipok
But we can create some encoter (like XviD or AMR)
and built it in ffmpeg

In that source there is some examples to create new FAAC encoder

Posted: 13 Jun 2006 14:08
by sean_malice
If it is not GPL compatible then i understand why this hasn't been done.
Hope someone will provide a workaround somehow.

Thanks.

Posted: 16 Jun 2006 20:05
by Guest
Yeah, I think those workarounds are called vorbis and mp3. :wink:

Posted: 01 Jul 2006 23:20
by Guest
Here's another good alternative workaround.:
http://mediacoder.sourceforge.net/

Re: AAC+ encoding through 3GPP spec. sources

Posted: 22 Feb 2011 11:40
by burek
vorbis and mp3 can't be a workaround, because the quality of aac+ at the bitrate of 32kbps cannot even be measured with vorbis nor mp3 at those bitrates.. we have to face it sooner or later that aac+ is the future.. all the online radio stations are switching to aac+ rapidly, video providers (like youtube) have already switched to h264/aac+ and it is just the matter of time until vorbis/mp3/(insert your favorite codec here) are forgotten..

gpl or not it's the best audio codec so far and it should be considered like that.. of course noone can force developers to do anything against their will, but as I can see, judging by replies on this forum, (almost) all the topics regarding aac+ enconding have been ignored, so i guess its just not gonna happen anytime soon, which means we'll have to look for another solution for encoding aac+, which is really sad, keeping in mind the popularity that VLC has had, having the nickname "swissarmy knife for audio/video"..