Page 1 of 1

Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 04 Sep 2020 17:04
by put1
I have an Android Samsung Galaxy A20E. While playing videos on VLC? the notch takes up space where the video should be.

I tried the resize option but none of the available options are satsifactory.

Is there any fix to this ?

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 07 Sep 2020 07:15
by Aza
Do you still get it when you choose the "Best fit" resize option?

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 07 Sep 2020 12:43
by put1
No, but the ratio is not right, the image is flattened.

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 08 Sep 2020 06:23
by Aza
Could you please provide a screenshot? The best fit option should keep the video original ratio.

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 09 Sep 2020 17:34
by put1
ok I got it wrong somehow, the ratio is good with best fit, but the notch is still taking part of the video
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/ ... 24_VLC.jpg

Of course you can't see it here

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 10 Sep 2020 05:58
by Aza
I just tried on a device with a notch and wa not able to reproduce. Do you use a custom ROM?

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 10 Sep 2020 10:35
by Lotesdelere
The movie seems to have a 2.39:1 aspect ratio, maybe that's the reason why.

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 10 Sep 2020 16:30
by Lotesdelere
I've just tried on an A51 which has a similar screen design. There is a small difference between the models though: the A20E has a 2.1666 aspect ratio (1560*720) whilst the A51 one is 2.2222 (2400*1080).
They don't really have a notch, there is only the camera lens bit and yes, with 2.39:1 movies, this part is indeed inside the video.

But I think Samsung does that by design, an image can use the whole screen:
Image

Larger pic:
https://s12emagst.akamaized.net/product ... 5_full.jpg

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 10 Sep 2020 19:44
by mederi
Missing "hide notch" option for wider videos.

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 11 Sep 2020 09:06
by Aza
Internally, the app rely on the notch area declared by the system (so the manufacturer). If the manufacturer decided not to mention there is a notch, there is nothing we can do.

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 11 Sep 2020 14:57
by mederi
Tere is a manul "show/display notch" switch in Xiaomi's Mi Video player (Redmi 8 ). It is one of the few options there during playback and I find it useful, too. Disabled option just puts a black bar/pad there reducing the size of the screen for video playback. The bar is inactive (no touch response for menu/pause/play). VLC could have a similar option.

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 11 Sep 2020 19:20
by Lotesdelere
There is no similar option notch option on the Samsung player, it's displaying the image just like VLC does, using the whole screen including the notch.
However MPV is not using the notch part! So it's possible to do it.

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 30 Sep 2020 19:07
by mederi

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 01 Oct 2020 10:35
by Lotesdelere
Latest MPV version also has an option for playing the video with or without the notch.

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 12 Feb 2021 11:01
by imdsuzon
Latest MPV version also has an option for playing the video with or without the notch.
Can't VLC add this type of option?

Re: Issue with my Android Notch infringing on the video

Posted: 17 Feb 2022 09:26
by Semicolonhope
Internally, the app rely on the notch area declared by the system (so the manufacturer). If the manufacturer decided not to mention there is a notch, there is nothing we can do.
This issue still hasn't been resolved. Videos extend under the notch and there's no setting to disable it. Many apps while in landscape mode — video players or not — are able to detect the notch. VLC itself detects the notch on media browsing screens. It's just the media player screen that doesn't detect the notch.