Page 1 of 1
Skin Compatability
Posted: 22 Oct 2008 11:21
by Bellerophon
Hi Guys,
I am a new member, just joined. I recently downloded some of the great skins done by users, one thing that did occur to me, after finding 4 out of 6 didn't work correctly on my system, VISTA Ultimate 32bit, maybe it would be an idea to add compatibility somewhere ie whether the skin is Vista compliant. XP etc. Perhaps this could also be added as a filter on the skins main page on the vlc site in addition to rating, newest etc.
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 22 Oct 2008 12:07
by Bellerophon
Looks like the problem is that many of the skins are not compatible with the new version of vlc, as stated in this post
viewtopic.php?f=15&t=51671. Perhaps in addition to compatibility with an OS, we need compatibility with a VLC version number?
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 22 Oct 2008 12:29
by Jean-Baptiste Kempf
Can you list the ones that don't work ?
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 22 Oct 2008 12:31
by 3breadt
If he uses 0.9.4 I'd guess all that use PNGs w/ transparent pixels, which are
ASkin
Blissta
Dalin Media Player
Dark
Default
Default -- please stay polite --
Default Remix
D-GFX Dark Skin
DPlayer
Eminence
Heaven
Homecinema
iPod
Media Player
My Simple Skin
nWMP11
psVLC
Relaxed
truc-2
VLC for kids
vlctch
vplayer
WB
(no guarantee)
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 22 Oct 2008 12:59
by Jean-Baptiste Kempf
It might be linked to the libpng security issue.
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 22 Oct 2008 13:07
by ssbssa
i think it is. i compiled vlc (0.9-bugfix) with libpng-1.2.32 and the partly transparent test-skin worked.
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 22 Oct 2008 13:23
by Jean-Baptiste Kempf
i think it is. i compiled vlc (0.9-bugfix) with libpng-1.2.32 and the partly transparent test-skin worked.
Your input is always usefull ssbssa! So it should be fixed in 0.9.5
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 23 Oct 2008 00:06
by Bellerophon
Hi, sorry forgot to mention version of vlc I dl'd the latest version yesterday, with regaurd to the list below blissta and heaven are OK, the others I had problems with are the askin, psp, nWMP11 and psVLC.
Can't seem to see an option on the blissta skin to get current vlc version.
Hope this helps.
If he uses 0.9.4 I'd guess all that use PNGs w/ transparent pixels, which are
ASkin
Blissta
Dalin Media Player
Dark
Default
Default -- please stay polite --
Default Remix
D-GFX Dark Skin
DPlayer
Eminence
Heaven
Homecinema
iPod
Media Player
My Simple Skin
nWMP11
psVLC
Relaxed
truc-2
VLC for kids
vlctch
vplayer
WB
(no guarantee)
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 26 Oct 2008 19:29
by howdr
I'm finding that most of the skins that are supposed to be for 9.0 or newer are still not working right with 9.4
Only the default one works right.
I have had to reinstall VLC many times to use it again
Vista 32 bit SP1
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 13 Apr 2009 13:42
by Mikie85
It usually takes some time to update skins to a new version and make it 100% compatible.
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 14 Apr 2009 02:35
by SanPuncho
I'm finding that most of the skins that are supposed to be for 9.0 or newer are still not working right with 9.4
Only the default one works right.
I have had to reinstall VLC many times to use it again
I've the same problem
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 18 Apr 2009 13:41
by 3breadt
Reinstalling VLC many times brings nothing, one uninstall and deleting the preferences folder (%appdata%/vlc) is enough. VLC leaves no other traces on the system. If you then install afresh and there still occur problems than its either a bug you can't do anything about or a compatibility issue with your system.
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 30 May 2009 19:54
by dal987
Hi, I've (unfortunately) wasted a lot of time trying to find any skins that really work with v0.9.9.
1. Incompatibility?
In particular, the current playing playlist item is usually not highlighted if a skin is applied, and right click on a playlist item is not available. In VLC default, these work. In many skins the '-' (delete) button in the playlist simply doesn't do anything.
That leaves the choice extremely limited.
2. A daily updated skin package?
This is curious, as the skin package is advertised as 'updated on a daily basis'. That implies these skins should work in general and are maintained.
3. Restrictive designs in many skins
Most skins I've tried are restrictive compared to the default. Indeed in a few there isn't even a volume control, and some fail to show the current title being played, and a couple show the whole path- or at least the start of it..
Perhaps that last is a comment about choices made in designing a skin.
4. In this version, are there really any usable winamp skins, or have I just been unlucky in not finding one that works? Yes, I've noted the distinction between 'Classic' and Skins 2.
I'd really appreciate advice, as I'm very surprised. I've used VLC for a long time, and this is my first serious attempt to find a skin for it.
Thanks, dal987
Vista Home Premium SP1.
Re: Skin Compatability
Posted: 31 May 2009 00:27
by Jean-Baptiste Kempf
Seriously, for skins, use VLC 1.0.0-rc2