The VideoLAN Forums

i can play 88.2K/24b 5.1 wav multichannel and 96k/24 (5.1 wav or flac multichannel)

...but i can't play 88.2K/24b 5.1 .flac multichannel (the flac file(s) is(are) perfect(s))

have any adjust that i unknow?
(i'm sure that i commit some stupidity as the player is cool)

all hints are apriciateds.
thanks all in advance.

I would guess that VLC doesn't support those files. You have some sample file you could share to us?

as the entire music have too big size, i'm sending a short multitrack 5.1 sample with 40Mb:

testeflac8824 5.1 multichannel.flac (RapidShare 40313Kb)

if needed more samples with more size for tests i can host (lots) too...

and thanks so much VLC_help,
reading the entire forum is easy to recognize that you're a great helper.

cheers

This file can only be downloaded by becoming a Premium member

This file can only be downloaded by becoming a Premium member

NO

just click in the link to download and select "Free user" as is showing this screenshot.

here the same link again:
testeflac8824 5.1 multichannel.flac




cheers and thanks for your interest to help too!

Ticket opened
trac.videolan.org/vlc/ticket/3144

hi again...
excuse to ask VLC_help, i really don't know:

what means "Ticket opened" ?

did you and j-b had time to download and test the flac88.2 file that i posted?

cheers

I tested it, and opened a trac ticket for this, so hopefully someone patches this in future.

Re: "This file can only be downloaded by becoming a Premium member"

Actually, I don't think j-b is referring to what to click on the download page for Rapidshare. About 3 weeks or so ago, Rapidshare tightened its restrictions considerably, and as a result people going to download anything from the service often get that error message during daylight (North American) hours. During the evening and early morning you can still download for free, but 9 attempts out 10 now if you attempt to access a file during daylight hours you'll be asked to either become a Premium Member or wait and try again later (I had to wait 6 hours once before a download slot opened up). The wording makes it appear as if the file is ONLY available to premium users, but I've yet to actually encounter this.

I got the file and I confirm the annoying bug.

Really surprised to see this. H264 + multi-channel FLAC in an MKV seems to be somewhat of a de facto standard for ripping and playing Blu-Rays from NAS. Hope to see a fix for this soon. Anyone know if this is a Windows-specific issue? Or all platforms?

I would guess that this bothers all platforms.

I have found 96/24 5.0 flac plays fine. As well as 96/24 stereo flac. 88.2/24 5.1 and stereo do not seem to play right though. If you upsample to 96/24 or down to 44.1/24 or whatever, it plays just fine.
TLDR: 88.2/24 playbacks appears to be totally broken.

I believe a trac ticket is already open now on this matter. Now someone should fix this.

Fixed for VLC 1.1

Fixed for VLC 1.1

this is completely GREAT

i thank so much the developer and helpers, great team, great player