Page 1 of 1

Subtitles stop auto-reopening after upgrade to 3.0.2

Posted: 02 May 2018 21:42
by depesz
I have a laptop wit some windows (7 I believe) that I use as source for projector. It's taking video files over mounted samba share.

I am currently using 2.2.8 and all works OK (well, there are some problems with video, but they are irrelevant for me).

Due to some talk, I upgraded to 3.0.2 and it stopped auto-opening subtitles. I have to go to subtitle menu, and click "add subtitle file" and then it works. Names for subtitle files are the same as video file, but with .txt extension.

I checked, on the same videos on 2.2.8, and it works OK.

So - am I missing something? Should I change/set something so that it will auto-open the subtitles?

Re: Subtitles stop auto-reopening after upgrade to 3.0.2

Posted: 03 May 2018 11:48
by Lotesdelere
I think automatic opening of TXT files has been removed.
You should use regular subtitles files, e.g. .SRT files.

Re: Subtitles stop auto-reopening after upgrade to 3.0.2

Posted: 03 May 2018 14:07
by depesz
Well, converting the files *is* an option, though I'd prefer something easier.

Given that I can open the subtitle manually, it seems that there is still support for reading them and guessing internal format. Is it literally not possible to get it to load automatically?

Re: Subtitles stop auto-reopening after upgrade to 3.0.2

Posted: 12 Nov 2018 13:04
by pitt66
IMHO, wrong design decision - people do use .txt and will switch over to a different player thinking that VLC is buggy because it cannot load subtitles.

Re: Subtitles stop auto-reopening after upgrade to 3.0.2

Posted: 14 Nov 2018 18:13
by RĂ©mi Denis-Courmont
People also use .txt for what it's meant: plain text. Matching it as subtitle format leads to a lot of false positives.

Re: Subtitles stop auto-reopening after upgrade to 3.0.2

Posted: 14 Nov 2018 22:39
by mederi