DJ: This is not a problem for VLC. If VLC is installed on a Windows XP system a pop up allows the selection of the player.
Yes---but to actually run the disc, you must then click the Play button (or File > Open Disc), then click OK to close the "Open..." window. That's three (or four) mental steps, compared to double-clicking an icon (a single step for most people).
I'm sure that some users don't mind dropping menus and opening and closing windows each time they want to play their discs. But personally (and my wife and friends who use VLC feel the same way), it's much faster and easier just to double-click an icon, and you're done.
That kind of functionality is why it's possible to add parameters to shortcut command lines. But you have to know
which parameters---and since VLC uses its own format for device paths, I felt it might help if I explained the details.
BTW, the "Open Disc" command does show "Ctrl+D" as its keyboard shortcut. I've tried that, but it doesn't work. Is it just my system? (I use the Dvorak keyboard layout, so that may have something to do with it---though I haven't had that problem with other apps.)
DJ: If you are not using XP There is an option in Preferences that allows you to select the drive making it easier to deal with various files from differing sources. This means never having to remember to type the drive letter in a menu.
"...various files from differing sources"? Aren't we talking here about setting
one drive for
one kind of source [CD or DVD]? Anyway, I think I know what you mean... But though I've looked through VLC's many options, I couldn't find the one you referred to. (I assumed it would be under "Interface"---no?)
I'm a pretty computer-literate guy. If I have trouble finding that setting (which seems pretty basic), other users may, too. Could this be
another reason why many people may find the icon method easier? (Is it my imagination, or do you seem philosophically opposed to icon shortcuts for some reason? I'm just trying to understand...)
As long as we're on the topic of VLC's UI, one more suggestion:
As I've mentioned, when you run VLC, clicking the Play button opens the "Play..." window. Wouldn't it make sense to have the Play button's shortcut (Spacebar) do the same thing? (It currently does nothing.) That would be another way to slightly speed up the disc-playing process.
DJ: Perhaps it would be better next time to ask questions BEFORE making a post a sticky... I can not change the state of this post so it will remain here for a few days until it's removed (deleted).
I didn't make it sticky. I just posted it---then I posted another message in your feedback section to suggest that one of
you make it sticky if you thought it was useful enough. Is it possible that one of your other admins thought it was good enough and made it sticky without telling you? (I'd never
assume one of my messages was good enough to be sticky---that'd be pretty vain!)
Cheers, Zeppy
(another grateful, and hopefully not too annoying, VLC user)