Please mark this [SOLVED]
I stumbled onto some "temporary" ml.xspf files (with trailing alphanumerics) in
I deleted them, and VLC instantly started behaving normally.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a720a/a720adc4d712f6ceb84ee01bbe257893ac371a53" alt="Smile :)"
)
I don't know how or why this occurred, but deleting those files certainly fixed my issue